Developing A Thesis for Common Ground and Points of Departure: Using NY Times A Room for Debate

by Lee Friederich | 24 Feb 2017
Resource Description: This activity engages students in the process of working together to develop a "they say" thesis statement for a synthesis essay based on The New York Times online forum "A Room for Debate," a website that clusters short, opinion-based articles about current topics by experts in their field. When teaching a class with many levels of readers, it is best to choose one of the debate forums to work with, either with the instructor choosing or students voting.  The activity elicits intensive collaboration and negotiation between partners, what Vaivanpanah and Miri (2017) call a "collaborative dialogue," a higher-level and more productive task type than the "simple dialogue." The activity can be used to practice synthesizing ideas and formulating a thesis, with or without going on to write a synthesis essay.
Audience: University
Audience Language Proficiency: Advanced
Duration: 75 minutes (reading prep takes place outside of class and/or during previous class period)
Materials and Technology:

Even when choosing one Room for Debate forum, the instructor should show the students the "Room for Debate" website so that students can understand the website and that the articles in a forum all address the same issue.  Copy and distribute all of the articles in the forum (usually 3-6 short articles) so that students can be read the articles carefully before coming to class.

Please see worksheet below.

Objective(s): Generating a thoughtful, complex thesis is one of the more difficult skills in a source-based writing class, particularly if students are not used to asserting strong ideas. This activity helps students gain experience in identifying over-arching main ideas in two essays, in particular "common ground" among authors and "points of departure," before bringing these ideas together into a synthesizing "they say" thesis. Using Graff's famous "they say, I say" construction, students will go on to add an "I say" statement to complete their thesis after the activity. The activity provides a rhetorical template for common ground and then a  "However, while" statement that allows students to show how the authors' ideas differ or "depart" from one another.
Outcome(s): Using a common ground and then a "However while" template students will go away from the activity with the first part of a "they say/I say" thesis. Negotiating which overlapping ideas constitute "common ground" and "points of departure," students will gain experience in identifying and synthesizing main ideas with the help of a partner.
Activity Description: After spending time in the previous class reading and discussing all of the short articles in the forum, students form partnerships to choose the two articles they think offer both "common ground" in terms of the authors' opinion or approach to the issue at hand and "points of departure" in which the authors either outright disagree or propose different solutions or ways of thinking about a problem.  Once the students have chosen the two articles they will work with, they chart common ground and points of departure on the enclosed worksheet and then compose two sentences together, first showing common ground and then a contrasting "However, while" statement to present points of departure to complete the "they say" part of the thesis.  Both sentences can be written on large pieces of newsprint to be displayed and discussed at the beginning of the next class, when students can then add their "I say" part of the thesis statement, which they should compose independently as homework.
  1. Graff, G., & Birkenstein, C. (2010). They say / I say: The moves that matter in academic writing. New York: W.W. Norton & Co.
  2. Kaivanpanah, S. and Miri, M. (2017), The Effects of Task Type on the Quality of Resolving Language-Related Episodes and Vocabulary Learning. TESOL Journal. doi:10.1002/tesj.311
Useful Links:

NY Time A Room for Debate


Uploaded Files:

11 reviews

Write a review
  1. imran | May 24, 2017
  2. kingroot | Apr 29, 2017

     KingRoot is the only and best app to root your device without any doubt. It can also get rid of the junk files after obtaining root without any harm, and it is probably safe enough to root your device.

    kingroot app

  3. john | Apr 28, 2017
    Thanks for Sharing! <a href="">products</a> Thanks for Sharing! [url=""]Click Here[/url]
  4. Lee | Apr 27, 2017

    Dear tesol organization ,

      I am Lee from Jilin Younovo Education company in China , I browse your website on internet and know you are doing tesol class training and granting tesol certificate . My company’s main business is inviting foreigners with tesol certificate to teach in china , I am wondering if we can cooperate to provide a chance for your students to work abroad after they finish the certificate . and I will pay you for the candidates that agree to work for my company, that will be good thing for both of our business , what do you think , if you are interested please do not hesitate to contact me , waiting for your reply . Wish you a nice day Company link:



  5. Durham Carpet | Apr 14, 2017
    For anyone that's looking to work with top custom home contractors, it's important to closely look at design trends that are popular currently in order to have the most impressive home in the area.

    Life just gets more hectic as time goes on, so why not have some part of mind? With so many things to worry about, you don't want to be concerned about your home and cleaning when you go on vacation.

    One of the greatest ways to discover opportunities to make income on the internet along with the help you require to turn into a winner with them is to look at work at home blogs. It really is interesting to note what you would discover when you do a Google search for the words "work at home blogs"

    Energy saving is a very good way to reduce global increased temperatures effects. Saving the surroundings should not be done in large thing. If you want to contribute, try to begin with saving energy in your home with energy efficient home concept.

    Many people are criticizing carpet as a flooring choice. It can definitely benefit your living areas, though. Keep reading, to learn what to consider regarding carpet as a flooring option in your home.

    Numerous people have a dream of being their own boss. What is very appealing is the allure of making your own hours and the chance for plenty of money. But, a large number of people are reluctant to strike out by themselves.

    Before one embarks on the abode upgrading plan it is important to plan for the desired results of the whole effort. What should be the focus area and why, has to be considered. Simply by cleaning up certain areas the house may obtain a fresh and clean look.

    Many people are curious about the things insider a recording studio room. It is not uncommon to see people are asking about this question because they are curios about the equipments inside a recording studio room because those equipments can lead to great music that they love.

    Interior house painting ideas are the simplest of ways to transform your liveable space easily, quickly and on a low budget. Doing it yourself and executing your creative house painting ideas would make it a point that the cost aspect is kept at the lowest.

    Organizing residence nightmares can be a really painful area of running your home based business. It could actually hamper the success of your business if you let it get out of control. Here are some easy tips to follow so you don't find yourself in this sticky situation.

    It wasn't too long ago that finding a truck accessories distributor meant a lot of work, miles and effort. These people are the lifeblood for most of our truck needs. There was a time we could drive the street and see them all over but

    Forever Living Products is a network marketing, yet most of its Distributors will not know the first thing about marketing. Find out the best way to get leads for your Forever Living Products business, here.

    In my 7 Day Belly Fun time Diet Review you're going to discover if the program is worth the money or if it will be just another waste of money water-downed fat loss system. Be sure to read this article before you invest in the 7 Day Belly Fun time Diet.

    The internet has changed lots of things of how people go about their daily routines. Communication has become that much clearer, finding friends and family is now a click away and searching for information is done in a moment. It is no question that a lot of things have changed now.

    One of those unfortunate ways to make money these days is through the get paid to go programs. People might be wondering whether these kinds of programs might be trustworthy, but truthfully, there are many scams, which might cheat the people.

    These days, online shopping is on the rise in India and this is due to the fact that online shopping is the most convenient and easiest ways of buying things for your home and for your family.

    Shopping is not called 'retail therapy' for no reason. It can cheer up an otherwise dull day by treating yourself to a new handbag or new tie. But, being savvy when spending to the key in a recession.

    Though the choices for corporate gifts can be found everywhere, sometimes you've still got a hard time mulling and shopping around that you get tired and realized how much time you have wasted hopping from store to another. In the internet, you can find almost all the things that you need.

    As if perpetually inviting skies and some of the world's most beautiful shorelines weren't enough, Southwest Florida offers an abundance of shopping methods of even the most discriminating buyers. Three signature landmarks illustrate the area's appeal.

    Los Angeles is known for its excellent shopping scene, which is mainly owed to the Hollywood stars who consistently need the latest and the best in fashion. Keen shoppers make the most of the city by planning before they start their shopping.

    Every woman searches for some chic and modern accessories to flaunt her style! If you are one of such women then this article is tailor made for you. We all know that these kinds of handbags make a really cute gift for any girl whether she's your girlfriend, wife or daughter.

    A fashion club has numerous options to choose from to complete community service. Project ideas include coat drives, collecting used clothing for disaster relief, raising money for a scholarship fund or supporting a famous fashion charity.

    Just because your wallet is feeling a pinch it doesn't mean you can't enjoy wearing the latest fashion trends. When was the last time you shopped in a discount store? If it's been a while you may be surprised at the affordable fashions you'll find in them.

    If you've ever gone shopping with a teenage girl you know that teenagers can be a very discriminating bunch!. Their physical and mental growth ' them refining all kinds of fashion items to improve their image and their look.

    Jewelry is functional and trendy often, from expressing your unique personality, enhancing your attire and enhancing your wardrobe ensembles. Engagement and wedding rings are the never-ending expression of your devoted love.

    In today's highly competitive business industry, subscribing to popular business and finance magazines are more important than previously. These trade magazines can help you become updated with the current trends in your business niche.

    Being at the cutting edge of business trends may help companies of all sizes stay afloat, but this needs to be done in a calculated manner. The right blend of marketing, admin, sales, support, and social media provides the key to success.

    In the eyes of a successful e-commerce business owner, a failing economy would not stop him or her to profit online. However, it may contribute as you factor to hinder the e-commerce business to grow, but it is not the sole reason other e-commerce business owners fail.

    The favorable conditions that helped drive the recent private fairness boom have changed dramatically over the past year. Future private equity returns will be much less than they were over the past 5 years and might end up being quite disappointing for many investors.

    Strategies to avoid most mistakes created by business beginners. Leaning experience is much positive attitude. Making mistakes is normal, but need to be discouraged. Strategies of making money fast are described in several ways.

  6. Mollie Wheeler | Apr 10, 2017
    The resources which are shared for us and it could help us more for the better learning's and that thing is more familiar to us and the duration is little bit more than we think but we should think of the fact that it could help us learn Write My Essay For Me many things which are retard impressive for our use and benefits and development of thesis on common ground is never easy for one who are enrolled in this and many students likely to fetch it some more things and they would explore it for the use of it.
  7. alvina ash | Apr 07, 2017
    That looks a great article for coursework writing service. We should take notes from this. 
  8. Jack kevin | Mar 16, 2017
    While drive-in offices, for example, those at fast-food foundations, banks, drug stores, and Part time job portal in Japan cleaners symbolize America's financial creativity, they likewise have influenced our own guidelines.
  9. Ragsdale | Mar 14, 2017
    Developing a thesis is also a really big challenge for the students, because their all results were enable in it, and This activity involves student in the procedure of employed together to change "they say" thesis report for a combination thesis based on The New York Times online forum "An Area for Discussion," a website that collections short, opinion-based training about recent topics by specialists in their field and students were <a href="">Buy Degree</a> from it and complete their thesis for there results.
  10. Brian Lara | Mar 14, 2017
    That looks a great article for writing an assignment. We should take notes from this.
  11. | Mar 08, 2017
    This is the way New York <a href="">database sql books </a>

    Write a review